The Anthem, the Indian, and the Chief Justice: Francis Scott Key, Marguerite Scypion, and the Road to Dred Scott
In 1838, the author of the words to America's future national anthem appeared before the United States Supreme Court on the side of a slaveholder attempting to overturn the freedom judgment of a woman descended from the Natchez Indians. His name was Francis Scott Key. The Chief Justice was Roger Brooke Taney, Key's brother-in-law. The woman at the center of the litigation was Marguerite Scypion.
The Supreme Court dismissed the slaveholder's appeal, leaving the favorable Missouri judgment undisturbed. Nineteen years later, Taney would deliver the majority opinion in Dred Scott v. Sandford. One case became a national symbol of denied freedom. The other remains far less familiar.

I. The Natchez Woman at the Foundation of the Case

Fort de Chartres, Illinois. Modern photograph of the historical site associated with the Natchez maternal ancestor described in the litigation. Source: Wikimedia Commons, Fort de Chartres 02Aug2007-32.
The Missouri court record traced Marguerite's claim through her mother, Marie Scipion, to a Natchez Indian maternal ancestor brought to Fort de Chartres in the French colonial period. The legality of that ancestor's enslavement under the successive colonial governments lay at the heart of the family's freedom claim. Her maternal descent was not incidental. It was the legal foundation of the litigation.
Original Missouri opinion: https://www.sos.mo.gov/Images/Archives/SupremeCourt/B150F13.pdf
II. The Color of Her Skin Was Questioned. Her Maternal Ancestry Secured Her Freedom.
The Scypion litigation illustrates why physical appearance, racial classification, and genealogical evidence cannot be treated as interchangeable. Historical testimony about the family included descriptions of complexion and hair texture and conflicting accounts of ancestry. Such testimony must be identified by witness and examined in context, not turned into an unsupported claim about the family's genealogy.
Marguerite's successful freedom claim depended upon Indigenous maternal descent. No unverified paternal ancestry should be presented as established fact. Nor should descriptions of dark skin or tightly curled hair be used to erase the Natchez maternal ancestry at issue in court. The precise wording of particular complexion and hair descriptions remains subject to verification against the original depositions.
III. A Family Fighting for Freedom
Marguerite's litigation was part of a broader family struggle. Missouri archival records identify related freedom proceedings involving members of the Scypion family, including Mary, Michael, Carmelite, Baptiste, Antoine, François, Joseph, Julie, and Catiche. These records remind us that a freedom judgment could affect the lives and legal status of multiple generations.
Missouri archival case listings: https://s1.sos.mo.gov/Records/Archives/ArchivesMVC/JudicialRecords/Detail?id=528787
IV. The Missouri Courtroom and the Question of Indian Slavery
Marguerite initiated her freedom action in 1825. Pierre Chouteau Sr. asserted that she was lawfully enslaved. Through successive proceedings, the courts considered the historical legal status of Indian slavery in the former Louisiana territory and the consequences of descent from an Indigenous woman. The Missouri litigation ultimately yielded a favorable judgment for Marguerite. Chouteau then attempted to obtain review in the United States Supreme Court.
The distinction matters: Missouri courts addressed the underlying freedom claim; the federal Supreme Court addressed whether it possessed jurisdiction to review the state judgment.
V. Francis Scott Key Appears in the Case

Francis Scott Key, author of the words to The Star-Spangled Banner and attorney named in the 1838 proceedings. Historical engraving reproduced in Alma Holman Burton, A History of the United States (1899).
Francis Scott Key, remembered for writing the words to The Star-Spangled Banner in 1814, was also a lawyer. His name appears in the official report of Choteau v. Marguerite, 37 U.S. 507 (1838): 'Key, with whom was Benton, opposed the motion.' The Benton identified was Thomas Hart Benton. The motion was to dismiss the slaveholder's attempt to secure federal review. Key argued against dismissal.
The name appears on printed page 509, immediately before the Court's decision. Although the page's running heading reads Garcia v. Lee, the Key passage precedes the divider introducing the next case and belongs to Choteau v. Marguerite. The red-circled image reproduces this passage.
Official report: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-37/pdf/USREPORTS-37-507.pdf

VI. The Chief Justice Was Key's Brother-in-Law

Chief Justice Roger B. Taney, Francis Scott Key's brother-in-law. Historical photograph, circa 1855 to 1860, reproduced in Carl Schurz, Reminiscences.
Roger Brooke Taney married Anne Phoebe Charlton Key, Francis Scott Key's sister. Key and Taney were therefore brothers-in-law. That family relationship is historically noteworthy, but does not itself establish judicial misconduct or improper influence. The documented connection is compelling without speculation.
VII. What the Supreme Court Actually Decided
The Supreme Court did not proclaim a nationwide end to Indian slavery, nor did it decide a broad rule of citizenship. The dispute before it concerned jurisdiction to review the Missouri judgment. The slaveholder's side invoked the Louisiana Purchase Treaty and asserted property protections. Justice Joseph Story explained the Court's decision. The motion to dismiss was sustained, and the writ of error dismissed. Marguerite's favorable Missouri judgment remained undisturbed.
VIII. Nineteen Years Before Dred Scott

Dred Scott, circa 1857. Historical photograph, photographer uncredited. His case followed the Scypion Supreme Court proceedings by nineteen years.
In 1857, Chief Justice Taney delivered the majority opinion in Dred Scott v. Sandford. The Scott litigation and the Scypion case involved different legal theories: the Scotts' claim concerned residence in free jurisdictions; Marguerite's concerned the legality of enslavement and Indigenous maternal descent. They should not be conflated.
Justice Benjamin Robbins Curtis cited Choteau v. Marguerite in his Dred Scott dissent in a discussion of federal territorial authority and the Louisiana Purchase Treaty, not as an Indian citizenship holding. The earlier litigation remained part of the Court's legal discourse even as its public memory faded.
Dred Scott opinion: https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/60/393
IX. The Fourteenth Amendment and the Meaning of Citizenship
Ratified in 1868, the Fourteenth Amendment repudiated the citizenship exclusion central to Dred Scott, but its text was not limited to descendants of enslaved Africans. The citizenship of American Indians maintaining tribal political relations remained a distinct constitutional issue, addressed in cases including Elk v. Wilkins (1884) and later legislation including the Indian Citizenship Act of 1924. Freedom, ancestry, tribal political relations, and citizenship must be analyzed separately.
X. Why the Scypion Victory Matters Today
How many Indigenous family histories have been obscured when later racial labels were treated as more authoritative than original genealogical and legal evidence? The Scypion litigation demands close attention to the records. A historical label such as 'woman of colour' did not negate the Natchez maternal descent that the litigation placed before the courts. The evidence must lead.
XI. The Victory America Should Remember
History has taught generations of Americans the name Dred Scott, whose freedom claim was rejected by the Supreme Court. But before Dred Scott, there was Marguerite Scypion, whose Indigenous maternal ancestry helped secure a victory against enslavement in the Missouri courts. Francis Scott Key appeared against dismissal of the slaveholder's appeal. His brother-in-law sat as Chief Justice. The appeal failed.
We have studied the chains of Dred Scott. It is time we studied the victory of Marguerite Scypion. Because American history must remember more than the freedom denied. It must also remember the freedom won.
Primary Sources and Research Notes
Choteau v. Marguerite (1838): https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/37/507
Missouri Supreme Court original record: https://www.sos.mo.gov/Images/Archives/SupremeCourt/B150F13.pdf
Dred Scott v. Sandford (1857): https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/60/393
The cover is a modern historical interpretation, not an authenticated portrait of Marguerite Scypion. The circled document reproduces the 1838 report. Specific witness descriptions of complexion and hair await direct transcription verification.
First Tribe Historical Research Institute | FirstTribeNation.com





Comments